Chapter 17
The Best of Family Fell Apart
Ethella found out?
How much did she hear? To what extent?
My mind went blank.
I'd always known that someday Ethella would find out.
I thought I’d be prepared when that moment came.
But because it happened so suddenly, all my defenses vanished.
"Ethella. Tell me what you heard."
Not knowing what to say, I desperately called her name.
The pain in my throat felt like something was raking over dry, cracked flesh.
Ethella—who always smiled at me with affection—glared instead.
She’d cried so much that her blue eyes were swollen and bloodshot.
"...Sister."
"Don’t touch me! You’re filthy!"
Her scream sliced through the room.
I heard the rough slide of skin against skin.
I looked down blankly at the back of my hand.
Red fingerprints bloomed where she’d slapped me away.
But that wasn’t why my hands were shaking.
Ethella’s contemptuous words struck far deeper.
My knees weakened and I took a few stumbling steps backward.
I sucked in a sharp breath.
I pressed my lips together.
I want to say it’s okay. I want to smile.
But my mouth was trembling too much.
"...Does your hand hurt?"
"Don’tpretendto care! How could you do that?!"
Resentment pierced me in that bright blue scream.
I should say no. Deny it. Tell her she’s wrong.
But Ethella didn’t know any of it.
She didn’t know her sweet, kind mother had been taken away because of me.
"It was because of you! Because of you, my mother disappeared!"
Ethella’s face was soaked with tears.
Droplets streamed down her jawline and fell.
I bit into the inside of my cheek so hard I tasted blood.
I can’t cry. Not in front of Ethella.
Unable to comfort her. Unable to hold her hand. I could only hang my head like a criminal.
I strained my eyes to keep the tears from falling—but everything below my line of sight blurred.
"Get out! You’re not even my sister! I hate you! Get out! I don’t even want to see you!"
In the end, Ethella sobbed bitterly.
Her cries—curled on her bed—pressed heavily on my shoulders.
The hand I’d extended toward her fell, helpless.
I forced my legs to move so they wouldn’t buckle.
Even that short distance felt like forever.
As soon as I opened the door, the maids standing outside pushed it fully wide.
"My lady!"
"Everyone, get out!All of you!"
The maids froze at Ethella’s scream.
It was the first time any of them had seen Ethella—eternal sunshine of the mansion—like this.
This is all because of the First Princess.
The maids filed out as if being chased, glaring at me.
What’s the point of walking upright if it all ends like this?
I didn’t notice their anger.
My once-straight shoulders trembled. My steps were unsteady. The rims of my eyes were red, holding back tears that never fell.
I don’t know how I made it to my room.
Once the door closed, I crumpled to the floor.
Just a while ago, I had been happy.
Flowers, necklaces, compliments. A gift from Ethella. A gift from the Grand Duke.
I should have known that unfamiliar happiness was a harbinger of misfortune.
I’d already experienced it once—and still, I’d been foolish enough to enjoy it.
Jade and Ethella—who had called me "Princess"—broke away like splinters, stabbing me.
I curled up, clutching at the searing pain ripping through old wounds.
My breath came hot and suffocating.
I always knew this would happen.
Jade. Ethella.
I thought the day would come when even Conrad—who had never stood beside me—and Father would turn completely away.
But it hurt most that even Ethella came to hate me.
As I struggled to breathe, my hand touched something hard at my throat.
My fingers found the pink diamond necklace—the Grand Duke’s gift. The one I’d so happily agreed to share with Ethella.
I let out a shaky breath.
Swallowing my tears, I shut my burning eyes.
I can’t let it end like this. Not without telling Ethella properly.
I pushed my broken heart back into my chest and stood up.
My legs shook, but I forced myself forward.
I have to go. Talk to her again. Tell her it wasn’t like that. If she listens—maybe...
A faint, desperate hope flickered.
When I stepped into the hallway, something felt off.
The maids were bustling about in a panic.
All of them were rushing toward Ethella’s room.
"Where’s the doctor?"
"I heard the young lady fainted!"
"She cried so hard... Her body is weak."
Someone’s sad voice floated by.
A sudden terror wrapped itself around my heart.
Ethella fainted.
I walked toward her room, my knees buckling so badly I had to brace against the wall.
Beyond the cluster of maids, I saw the Duke.
His usually slicked-back hair was slightly disheveled—as if he’d come running.
He spotted me and immediately frowned.
While I shivered at the chill in his gaze, the Duke strode toward me.
"Father..."
"You really don’t know how to doanythingright."
Suppressed anger weighed heavily upon me.
He glared, violet eyes blazing.
Even the servants rushing back and forth fell silent—but that didn't temper his rage at all.
"You couldn’t even obey one simple order—keep Ethella from finding out."
His words grated out between clenched teeth.
Those amethyst eyes held only cold condemnation.
Once he realized it was the anniversary of his wife's death—and Ethella had taken ill—his voice dropped even lower:
"Did you finally spread that filthy misfortune to Ethella as well?"
Thud.
Something inside me snapped.
My fists clenched reflexively.
"I wasn’t the one who brought you here."
The Duke covered his eyes with one hand and let out a deep, weary sigh.
Then, without caring that every word shredded me further, he walked past and muttered:
"If I could, I would erase you from my life."
My heart pounded as if it would burst.
A high-pitched ringing filled my ears; the world grew hazy.
This must be a nightmare.
Ethella fainting. Father’s words. All of it—lies within a bad dream.
We’re still family. They only hate me now—but it will pass. It has to.
Beyond my foggy vision, Conrad appeared, running.
I reached out to him as if grasping for salvation.
For an instant, I thought I saw a flicker of concern on his usually-expressionless face.
But his features twisted as soon as he met my eyes.
"Was it you again?"
"..."
"Was it not enough to take Mother? Now you’re going after Ethella too?"
Maybe he really does take after Father.
I blinked slowly.
If this is a nightmare, please let me wake up.
Conrad’s harsh words continued to hollow me out:
"I told you: if you don’t understand something, write it down and memorize it. Don’t go near Ethella."
After his chilling warning, he entered Ethella's room.
I felt something inside me—my second fragile support—collapse completely.
The expectations I’d held together so sloppily, even after they’d cracked, were now crushed beyond repair.
"Olivia!"
Jade’s voice, hot and frantic, shouted my name.
He bounded up from the bottom of the stairs and seized my shoulders violently.
I swayed like a paper doll in his grip.
"I told you—not to let Ethella find out! How can you fail even at that?!"
He growled like a wounded animal—his anger directed solely at me.
I met his eyes blankly as I rocked back and forth.
At that moment, I understood.
The day I longed for—the day my family smiles at me—will never come.
My "best" had always been insignificant.
My breath snagged in my chest.
I blinked slowly, hardly noticing Jade’s grip slacken.
My gaze wandered past him.
"You. I’ll go see Ethella first. Then I’ll come back—we’ll finish this conversation."
Jade issued the threat in a low voice, then hurried into Ethella's room.
I reached for my neck.
I clawed at the necklace, but the clasp wouldn’t come loose.
Gasping for air, I stumbled blindly down the hall.
In my blurred vision, I noticed staff looking at me with pity. A frozen Sally clutching flowers. A doctor rushing past.
And lastly—the family portrait hanging on the first floor.
"Ha..."
A hollow laugh slipped out.
As if my tears had dried out, my vision sharpened.
There I was—my younger self—alone and stiff, standing awkwardly amongst the Madeleine family.
Poor, foolish Olivia.
I was never meant to be in that picture. Why didn’t I see it sooner?
I laughed emptily.
Unlike the crowded staircase, the ground floor was deserted.
I opened the heavy door—and stepped out of the mansion.
A pitch-black night draped itself over the garden.
Where should I go?
My thoughts moved sluggishly.
A nearby inn, perhaps. Anywhere seemed better than this mansion.
The knights at the gate looked at me with questioning eyes, sensing my presence.
I said nothing. As soon as I walked forward, one of them opened the gate for me.
When the tall iron doors parted, I stepped out of House Madeleine.
I looked up at the sky and inhaled.
The tight band around my chest loosened just enough for me to breathe.
"Miss?"
A languid voice washed over me.
I turned my head.
The Grand Duke stood there, his back to a large carriage.
He waved casually.
The jeweled pin in his hand sparkled under the moonlight.
"I came to return this jewelry pin."
His words faded into the air.
The portrait in my mind remained sharp—but strangely, his face felt out of focus.
I shrugged my shoulders.
"Good evening, Your Highness the Grand Duke."
My voice—calm on the surface—cracked in odd places.
I coughed a little after each phrase. My throat burned.
The Grand Duke rushed over and stopped in front of me.
"What happened? Something’s wrong."
I spoke in fragments—and then laughed weakly.
His worried, youthful face looks almost comical. Why does he always look at me like that?
Why does he make such a sad expression—just for me? Not even my family has shown me a face like that.
It was an impulse.
The kind that rises up suddenly just from seeing him.
I raised the corner of my mouth into a crooked grin.
"Just how nice can you be to me?"
"...You can likely count on one hand the things Iwon’tdo for you."
"Then... please help me."
Because I have nowhere else to go.
I swallowed the rest and laughed faintly.
Facing my tear-dried green eyes, his red eyes almost seemed on the verge of overflowing.
Without my noticing, his hand clenched into a fist.
This was the Grand Duke's residence.
A gorgeous, elegant room—not a gloomy lair as rumors suggested.
There were rumors of a dark dungeon hidden beyond the fortress gates.
But the place he led me into rivaled any aristocratic mansion in the capital.
"Rest. I want this place to be somewhere you feel at ease."
I thought back to his words and let out a short laugh.
The Grand Duke was quick to sense the mood.
He’d tactfully omitted the second half of that familiar phrase—
"Think of it as your home."
Maybe I’d been too obvious. Leaving my house at this hour...
A heavy sigh slipped from my lips.
Now that my shoulders and the backs of my hands had relaxed, the pain throbbed loudly.
I tried to ignore the red, swollen skin on my hand.
Instead, I filled my mind with plans. For the first time in a long time, they felt... clear.
A knock sounded at the door.
I answered, and a maid entered.
She resembled Sally a bit—except her hair was a pale straw color.
"Nice to meet you, my lady. I’m Hannah, the Grand Duke’s maid. I came to ask if you’re uncomfortable or need anything."
Her face was young and nervous.
Hannah brightened when I smiled.
"I’m very comfortable. It’s... nice. Thank you."
It was true.
I hadn’t brought any luggage, yet my wardrobe was filled with dresses, nightgowns, shoes, and even jewelry—all tailored to my size.
The Grand Duke had prepared everything beforehand.
"Please speak comfortably, my lady. You’re an honored guest of the Grand Duke. If you need anything, just pull this cord. I’ll come immediately."
"Anything?"
"Yes! His Highness told us to dowhateveryou want!"
Hannah looked excited.
At that eager expression, I made a small request.
After hearing it, Hannah blinked repeatedly.
"...Are you really leaving tomorrow morning? And with a carriage that bears no crest? Are you sure that’s all right?"
"It’s more than enough."
I grinned.
When Hannah left, I curled up on the bed in the unlit room.
No matter how small I made myself, my stomach still felt broken.
It was a night without sleep.
Every time I closed my eyes, their faces appeared.
I ground my teeth.
Don’t cry.
But as the darkest hour before dawn crept in—when the night is blackest—my eyes grew faintly wet, unseen by anyone.
Pale morning light slipped through the floor-to-ceiling windows.
The Grand Duke stood there, staring out.
A carriage was crossing the garden, heading toward the gates.
"The young lady is on her way to the imperial palace."
Howard reported in a low voice.
The Grand Duke watched until the carriage vanished beyond the gate.
When it was gone, he looked down at the note in his hand.
Thank you for your kindness, Your Highness.I am still the fiancée of His Highness the Crown Prince,and I have decided to live in the Crown Prince’s palace for the time being.I will invite you as soon as possible.— To the one who is always kind.Olivia Madeleine
"...You’re a clever girl. Then and now."
A sigh lingered at the end of his seductive murmur.
The Grand Duke looked over his desk with wistful eyes.
There was a neat pile of colorful envelopes.
The sender’s name—written in elegant handwriting—was the same on every one:
Liv Green.