Chapter 16
I Thought It Was a Perfect Day
"But what did the guest behind us come here for?"
Madame Deaton greeted the Grand Duke with her best business smile.
The Grand Duke didn’t answer.
Seeing the suspicious robe and his silence, Madame’s hand slipped discreetly below the glass case.
She’s about to ring for the guard—
"He’s someone I know."
I spoke quickly.
The quick-witted Madame blinked.
The Princess—who’d received the oath that caused such an uproar last night—had come in person, supposedly to choose a gift for a man other than her family or the Crown Prince.
And now she claimed to know this robed stranger.
Madame understood at once and gave me an inexplicable smile.
Then she bowed politely to the Grand Duke.
"...Very well. I’ll bring up some new refreshments. Everyone will wait outside—please ring the bell if you need anything."
Without another word to me—who was still flustered by her very clear misunderstanding—Madame left the room.
As if he'd been waiting for that moment, the Grand Duke took off his robe.
That gorgeous, wordless face curved into a playful smile.
"What if Ilikebeing helped this way? Must I really keep getting into trouble?"
"What is that supposed to mean!"
I snapped back without thinking—then realized my slip.
Hastily, I held the hem of my dress and gave my best curtsey:
"Olivia Madeleine greets Your Highness the Grand Duke."
"I think you can stop with that greeting."
"It's etiquette."
"I'd like to grant you a privilegeaboveetiquette, my lady—to speak to me informally. As a sign of our closeness. How about it?"
I blinked slowly.
An informal greeting was a privilege reserved for those who shared a truly close relationship—respecting each other beyond rank.
I have never heard that even from Leopold, whom I’ve known since I was nine.
The Grand Duke watched my expression keenly, then changed the subject as if nothing had happened.
"Didn’t you have something you wanted to tell me?"
Ah.
Only then did I remember why I’d looked for him, and narrowed my eyes.
"What did you mean by what you said earlier?"
"What are you referring to?"
"The ring. It’s a wedding proposal ring—why would you give it tome?"
I couldn’t even finish my sentence.
The Grand Duke asked back as if genuinely curious:
"Well—how else am I supposed to know exactly what you like?"
Joke or serious?
I instinctively searched his face.
The Grand Duke averted his gaze. Through the jet-black hair at his nape, I caught a glimpse of ear tips stained red.
Don’t be ridiculous, Olivia.
Startled by my own thought, I shook my head quickly.
I heard the Grand Duke laugh quietly—but I didn’t feel embarrassed.
It’s a silly assumption. He’s a Grand Duke. I’m just overreacting to his jokes.
I tried hard to suppress my blush and responded more playfully, ignoring my racing heart:
"If you joke like that, you’ll end up in a wedding hall."
He was not only the Empire’s sole Grand Duke, but a war hero with immense wealth and fame. Even the Emperor had paraded him as the “best groom” yesterday.
I smiled proudly, hoping he’d take it as a compliment.
But when the Grand Duke looked at me again, his expression was... odd.
His searching red eyes made me second-guess myself.
Itwasa compliment... did I say it wrong?
Just as I began to worry, the Grand Duke smiled sweetly.
"...That’s exactly what I’m hoping for."
"...With me?"
"Yes. Withyou, my lady."
My heart swelled at his clear answer.
I felt like I needed to say something—but as soon as our eyes met, my words died on my tongue.
Why does he look at me like that?
A gaze so warm and ticklish that it was almost uncomfortable to receive.
Those eyes contained everything I’d always longed for.
Sweet affection.
He’d been kind to me from the very beginning.
Had it all been... intentional?
Or did something change somewhere along the way?
There were countless questions I wanted to ask.
But what I actually said was:
"I am the fiancée of His Highness the Crown Prince."
The Grand Duke’s gaze drooped as though displeased with that truth.
With that sulky, puppy-like expression, I felt like I’d done something wrong.
"I know. But you like that ring too, don’t you?"
"Of course I like the ring, but..."
Halfway through my automatic answer, realization dawned—and I glared at him.
The Grand Duke quickly raised his hands in surrender.
"All right, all right. Then—what brings you here today?"
"I came to choose a gift for Your Highness."
"You were choosing a gift forme?"
He lit up like an excited child.
I felt a bit guilty and confessed honestly:
"The jewelry pin I gave you yesterday was actually a gift from my younger sister. Something she cherishes..."
"...You’re not saying you intend to take back the gift you gave me, are you?"
"That’s exactly what I’m saying. I’ll give you a different gift in exchange."
The Grand Duke pursed his lips, full of disappointment.
Uncharacteristically, I added a clumsy excuse:
"Of course, I wish I’d given you something else from the start. But, as you know, the situation was urgent."
"...There’s one way for you to get your jewel back, you know."
"Which one do you like?"
I quickly scanned the display case—excluding, of course, the Grand Duke’s ring.
For cufflinks, maybe obsidian or diamonds would be best...
The Grand Duke pointed towards one section of the stand:
"How about that one?"
He was pointing at an emerald necklace.
A deep, bright green—like summer forests.
Emeralds shone between tightly woven platinum links. It was mesmerizing.
I looked back and forth between the necklace and the Grand Duke.
"Uh... Are you going to wear it yourself?"
"It’s for you."
He spoke bluntly, meeting my confused gaze.
"In exchange for me returning the jewelry pin, please accept this. Otherwise, I won’t give it back."
"I should be the one giving, but you want me to accept a giftagain?"
"You’re the one who said you’d do anything."
He came out shamelessly.
I was about to retort that I’d never said such a thing—but the truth was, I’d listen to almost anything the Grand Duke asked.
Still... that color...
"It’s not that I don’t like it, but I don’t really suit bright colors."
"What’s that supposed to mean?"
The Grand Duke frowned.
I shrugged, keeping my expression bland.
"I know it doesn’t suit me. So can I pick something darker?"
While I stared into the display, the Grand Duke studied me.
My gray dress was simple but well-made. No earrings. No necklace.
He probably thinks I like plain things.
Bitter amusement twisted his mouth.
He swallowed the taste and spoke lightly:
"...As I said yesterday, it seems like the people around you have no sense of aesthetics whatsoever."
"Pardon?"
I turned back toward him.
My face clearly read:I don’t understand.
His anger only grew because the target was so obvious in his mind—
A foolish Crown Prince who can’t recognize what’s precious—things, or people.
The Grand Duke ground his teeth and muttered:
"I suppose we’ll need to consult an expert."
He rang the bell lightly.
As if she’d been waiting, Madame returned.
Her gaze faltered for a moment upon seeing the Grand Duke without his robe.
"I greet the great war hero, His Highness the Grand Duke."
"You’re quick to understand—a useful trait. I assume your mouth can also stay shut."
"Thank you. What do you require, Your Highness?"
"Bring out every bright-colored necklace that would suit the Princess."
"Bright... for me?"
I protested—but the Grand Duke didn’t seem to hear me.
Neither did Madame, whose eyes shone as she rushed to bring the jewels.
Before I knew it, a clear pink diamond had been placed at my throat.
"Oh my! I always thought this piece would be perfect for the Princess!"
My mouth went dry.
The brighter the jewels, the duller I’ll look.
My hands fidgeted, having lost their purpose.
When the Grand Duke said nothing, I lowered my head further.
"How is it, Your Highness?" Madame asked excitedly.
"...Better than I expected."
I closed my eyes tightly at the deep voice.
In the darkness, Leopold's sarcasm echoed:
"Didn’t I tell you? Bright colors really don't suit you."
Another voice overlaid it:
"I’m surprised—it suits you even more than I thought."
I slowly opened my eyes.
The Grand Duke, leaning casually against the display case, nodded.
"It suits you very well. What you’re wearing right now mixes both dark and bright shades."
From the tips of my toes to the top of my head, something fizzy and strange rose up.
It’s my first time hearing anything like this...
I glanced at the mirror.
I’d always insisted I didn’t suit bright colors. That even Ethella’s pink necklace didn’t look right on me.
But the woman in the mirror... wasn’t bad.
No—that might be too modest.
She looked... a little bit lovely.
The Grand Duke shrugged, as if wondering if his judgment was correct.
Madame kept piling garnets, rubies, sapphires at my throat.
"Just one... I misspoke. Can’t I give you all of them?"
"One is more than enough, Your Highness."
He pouted at my sharp refusal.
Behind me, Madame nearly squealed—but suppressed it.
The way the Grand Duke looks at the Princess is... not normal at all.
The Grand Duke insisted on accompanying me back.
Sally, beaming, went ahead with our packages.
Inside the carriage, I absentmindedly played with the pink diamond necklace at my throat.
"As promised, I’ll return the jewelry pin by tonight."
His red eyes curved gracefully. It was obvious he was in an excellent mood.
I laughed softly—then stopped.
Suddenly, his previous words came back to me.
A ring. A proposal ring.
The Grand Duke was kind, attentive, openly affectionate.
If all of that was for the sake of a marriage proposal—I had to stop it.
Because I had to become Crown Princess.
Only by standing proudly next to Leopold would my family look at me.
My hand froze at my necklace. A heavy ache sank into my heart.
I didn’t know it would hurt this much to decide I shouldn’t see him anymore.
"Your Highness, there’s something I need to tell you."
"What is it?"
"About the ring you mentioned earlier."
"...Have you finally decided you want it?"
The Grand Duke, who had been reclining, sat up straight.
His red eyes shone sweetly.
"It’s a bit late, but if my lady says she wants it, I’ll reconsider."
His tone was lazy, but his movements were quick as he reached into his coat for the ring case.
"It’s not that. It’s about... why you’re nice to me."
Feeling his gaze, my voice shrank.
"If you're only kind because of a marriage proposal—you don’t have to be."
The Grand Duke’s expression turned complicated.
His lips pressed together, as if he were holding back sharp words.
I’m doing something terribly wrong.
He must think I’m shameless—after everything he’s done.
My shoulders sagged.
At the same time, his calm voice cut through the air:
"Is that what you think? That I’m only being 'nice' to you?"
He sounded genuinely puzzled.
I nodded.
"Yes. You’ve been so good to me."
I’ve never felt such generous affection before. Unfamiliar compliments. Warm eyes. Thoughtful gestures. Kind words. Even gifts.
I was truly grateful.
For a moment, the Grand Duke’s face twisted—as if my gratitude had wounded him.
Then his smile returned, a little brittle at the edges.
"Then I suppose I’ll just have to treat you even better."
"...Why?"
"Because I’ve been suppressing the urge to do more. Approaching you as gently and non-threateningly as I can."
His words felt like sunlight in early spring—soft and painfully bright.
Can I really dare to taste kindness like this?
The Grand Duke chuckled.
"So don’t ever tell me not to be nice to you. All right?"
My throat felt parched.
After a moment, I nodded.
He smiled gently.
Before long, the carriage stopped in front of the mansion gate.
The Grand Duke stepped down, then glanced beside me.
At some point, without my noticing, another jewelry box had appeared on the seat.
Before I could protest, he spoke first:
"That one’s for your younger sister. I’d like to stay on the good side of your precious sibling as well."
He smiled and signaled the carriage to depart.
The gate opened, and my carriage rolled through the garden.
I looked out the window and watched him walking away.
Even from a distance, I could see his smile clearly.
Once inside the mansion, I opened the box he’d left behind.
Inside was a pink diamond necklace—the exact same one I was already wearing.
For some reason, my heart fluttered.
I really did think—it was a perfect day.
I’d received flowers and gifts from children. And from him.
"Sally?"
I called for her, expecting her to greet me as usual.
But she was nowhere to be seen.
Several of my maids were gathered in one hallway instead.
In front of Ethella’s room.
The maids—standing there with worried faces—noticed me.
"My lady, Lady Ethella is looking for you."
"Ethella’s back?"
She wasn’t due home for another three days.
A sick feeling stirred in my chest—but I shook my head.
What could be wrong? She must have had fun at Mother’s family estate...
I pushed open Ethella’s door—and froze.
Even though it was evening, the room was dark. No lamps lit.
In the fading sunset light, I saw Ethella sitting on her bed.
She sensed me and turned toward the door.
Her face was hidden by her hair.
I opened my mouth to call her name—then stopped.
This feeling... It’s like when I first stepped into Father’s study.
"...Sister."
Her voice was cracked, screeching.
I set the box down on the table and stepped toward her.
"What’s the matter?"
It was a crying voice.
A very, very tired voice.
I clenched my fists.
Who dared make Ethella cry? Angelic Ethella?
It should be impossible.
"Tell me. What happened?"
"Because of you... I... really..."
Ethella slowly lifted her head.
I stopped dead.
Ethella’s eyes—those eyes that always sparkled with happiness—were sunken and dark.
"Did my mother die... because of you?"
Her trembling voice pointed straight at me.
My heart plummeted.