Chapter 54
“Is that so?
To think of others first… that’s unexpected.
Did she truly come out of that convent having repented?”
“I don’t know for certain, but it definitely seems like she’s being extremely cautious about getting involved with men.”
“Well, she was hurt by love and even abandoned by her family… Ah!
That was a slip of the tongue!
Haha!”
Bella loathed the growing sentiment of sympathy for Harriet.
She had worked so hard to paint Harriet as a pathetic, unsightly nuisance who didn’t deserve an ounce of pity.
Yet, after only a year, people were treating her like a tragic heroine ‘scarred by love.’ They were even whispering that the Listerwell family had ‘abandoned’ her.
‘Regardless of all that, why must Harriet be the topic of conversation at MY party!’
Bella clenched her fists.
She feigned urgent business to step away and found Carolyn.
“Carolyn.
Tell them to bring out the gifts.”
“Huh?
Already?
Weren’t those supposed to be handed out when people leave?”
“Can you just do as I say?”
“O-okay, I got it.”
Noticing Bella’s foul mood, Carolyn hurried to the preparation room.
A moment later, Cheslow servants began distributing gifts to the guests one by one.
Receiving a gift in the middle of a party felt somewhat abrupt.
Once Bella confirmed everyone had received theirs, she tapped a thin wine glass with a silver spoon, creating a clear, ringing sound.
“I’ve prepared these gifts to express my gratitude to everyone attending our party today.
It’s the bestseller cream from, a brand famous for its luxury beauty products.”
Exclamations of “Oh!”
erupted from various spots.
creams were not only expensive but so popular they were notoriously difficult to obtain.
Bella allowed herself a triumphant smile.
“Gentlemen, you’ll earn a lot of points if you gift this to your mothers, sisters, or lovers.
And the ladies here already know just how wonderful this cream is.”
Since the cream cost 500 diram per unit, providing full-sized versions for everyone was a heavy financial burden.
To manage this, Bella had negotiated with the owner of .
She commissioned a special production of half-sized jars for the gifts at a lower price, and in exchange, she agreed to tuck a pamphlet into each gift pouch.
It was Bella’s chosen method to show off while cutting costs.
“ is a brand I’ve personally used for a long time.
The products are so excellent that I truly wanted to recommend them to all of you.
I hope you enjoy the gift.”
A round of applause followed.
Bella expected the talk of cheap soap and Harriet to vanish, replaced by praise for her and the cream.
However, an unwelcome atmosphere began to stir.
“Are we supposed to carry this around until the party ends?”
“I know.
This is a bit inconvenient…”
Harriet had also distributed gifts during her tea party, but at that time, everyone was seated, and the gifts could simply stay on the tables.
An evening party was different.
If guests left the gift somewhere, it might get lost, but carrying it around was a nuisance.
Eventually, Bella had to deploy the servants again to collect the gifts, telling guests they could pick them up at the exit when they went home.
Beside her, James let out an awkward laugh.
“Why did you hand them out so early?”
“I was worried some might leave early.
I suppose I was foolish.”
Bella managed a tight smile for James, who was being tactless enough to chide her.
She knew perfectly well that handing out gifts mid-party was a poor move.
‘But I had to cut off the talk about Harriet somehow!’
The only thing capable of diverting everyone’s attention was bringing out the gifts.
She had endured this humiliation, but she told herself it was a success as long as she didn’t have to hear about that damn soap anymore.
Right then, she overheard Viviana speaking to another lady nearby.
“If you like , I’ll give you mine when we leave.
It doesn’t really suit my skin.”
Bella shot a sharp, piercing glare at Viviana, but Viviana didn’t notice at all.
‘I poured money into thinking I’d end up with skin like Bella’s, but it did nothing for my acne.’
The only good thing about using expensive cosmetics was the feeling of superiority it gave her in front of others.
Now that she thought about it, she wondered how much people must have mocked her behind her back.
Having found a product that actually worked for her, she didn’t mind giving away the expensive cream at all.
Carolyn, who had approached unnoticed, nudged Viviana in the side.
“Bella gave those out as a gesture of thanks to her guests.
Is there really a need to say things like that right now?”
Viviana knit her brows at the criticism.
“If I don’t say it now, when should I?
It’s a product I won’t use even if I take it home, so it’s better if someone else gets it.
It’s not like I said something bad…”
“Ha, Viviana.
I’ve thought this for a while, but you really lack tact.
Going to that tea party Harriet hosted was one thing, but this…”
“Other girls went there too, not just me.”
“Forget it.”
Viviana felt a surge of anger at Carolyn’s condescending attitude, as if she were looking down on a social inferior.
‘She’s always like this.
Does she think she’s someone special?’
Viviana turned to Bella, intending to say something about Carolyn’s behavior.
But for a split second, the look she caught in Bella’s eyes was chillingly cold—to the point where she wondered if this was truly the Bella she knew.
It couldn’t even be dismissed as a misunderstanding.
The moment Viviana tried to speak, the cold-eyed Bella sharply turned her head away.
Suddenly, Harriet’s words flashed through her mind.
“Why is Bella so concerned about me?
Since when did she care?
Don’t you agree?”
Yes, that was right.
Bella had never been concerned about anyone else’s feelings.
Not Harriet’s, and certainly not her friends’.
She always moved exactly as she pleased, and it was her friends—including Viviana—who had spent years sugar-coating her actions.
‘Is Bella truly a “good” person?’
The suspicion that arose instinctively pulled an old, buried memory to the surface.
Bella, who knew full well that Viviana liked Adam Hopfner, yet placed the bouquet she received from him on the refreshment table as if it were a trophy.
Bella, who bragged about how Adam preferred women with beautiful skin.
Everyone else had walked on eggshells around Viviana that day, but Bella hadn’t.
Viviana had convinced herself there was no malice behind it… but was that really true?
Feeling uncharacteristically defiant today, Viviana let out the words she had been holding back.
“What, is this a place where the world ends if we upset Bella?
Are we here as guests, or were we mobilized to be Bella’s bridesmaids?”
At those words, not only Carolyn but the other friends turned to look at Viviana in shock.
But she didn’t stop.
“Oh, that’s right.
We were always Bella’s bridesmaids, weren’t we?
My sin must be truly great for failing to flatter Bella in my role as a bridesmaid.”
“Viviana!
What is this insolence?”
Carolyn’s scolding didn’t scare her anymore.
“The insolent one is you, Carolyn!
You tell me I lack tact?
Fine!
Let’s say I don’t have it.
But why should I have to walk on eggshells around you or Bella?”
Viviana spat the words out as if venting years of accumulated resentment.
In truth, Bella’s friends all came from decent families.
While being grouped together with Bella had earned them the reputation of being ‘pretty and refined young ladies,’ that wasn’t necessarily thanks to Bella.
Viviana, who had always heard she was the ‘ugliest of Bella’s guard,’ no longer wanted to live like Bella’s servant.
When Viviana refused to back down, Bella finally approached with her eyebrows lowered in a worried expression.
“What’s going on, Carolyn?
Why is Viviana so angry?”
Viviana let out a hollow laugh.
‘She looked at me like I was a bug a moment ago, and now this.’
How had she failed to see this side of Bella for so long?
No, she hadn’t failed to see it.
There had been many times when she felt a strange chill from Bella’s actions.
She had simply looked the other way, telling herself, ‘I must have seen it wrong’ or ‘I’m just misunderstanding her.’
Nearby, other friends nudged Viviana.
“Viviana, what has gotten into you?
You’re going to make Bella cry.”
“This is Bella’s party; it’s not right to raise your voice.
Hurry up and apologize.”
Viviana looked around at her friends, Carolyn, and Bella.
Bella on the verge of tears, Carolyn with an arm around her shoulder, the friends looking at her with accusing eyes, and the other guests whispering and peeking to see what the commotion was about.
While it was absurd, she also felt like she had been in this exact situation before.
‘When was it?’
Searching her memory, Viviana suddenly realized.
‘Ah!
Back then, it was Harriet standing in this spot.’
It was about a year and a half ago.
At a tea party hosted by Bella.